Custom Cakes and Cupcakes

Our custom cakes and cupcakes can be designed to serve as a sweet centerpiece for your dessert table. Tennille is sought out for her creativity and ability to design unique masterpieces that compliment the theme and inspiration for any event.  Cake costs will vary based upon the detail and design of your custom creation, but the average cost range starts at $12 per slice. There is a minimum order of $350 for custom cakes or $150 cupcakes.


Sugar Cookie Favors

Tennille is well known for not only its boutique cakes, but also for ornate sugar cookie favors, which are available starting at $75/dozen with a 2-dozen minimum order. Cookies are artfully designed and crafted by hand and then individually wrapped in a crystal clear selo-bag or gift box of your choice with a beautiful matching ribbon and a personalized label.

Please Note:

All custom desserts are made to order. In order to ensure quality of service and product, all orders must be placed 4 weeks in advance. Some rush orders may be able to be honored on a limited basis – please inquire for more details. Delivery is offered at an additional charge beginning at $75, depending upon the location.


The Cupcake Carriage shop is open by appointment only, with all consultations & tastings scheduled in advance. Due to Covid restrictions we are currently not offering in-person consultations. However, you will be able to order a tasting to go, in addition to a virtual meeting scheduled on zoom to carefully go over the details. To ensure you get the most out of your consultation, Tennille requests that you provide anything that might be part of your inspiration, including: invitations, decorations, photos of your centerpiece, color scheme swatches, or any other elements that might help with the design. The cost of a custom consultation (including tasting) is $30. Consultations scheduled without tastings are free of charge. You will be required to provide a credit card to place your order for a tasting at the time of your booking. Cancellations must be made within 24 hours. Any cancellations made outside of this time frame will be charged a $20 fee.